So, you’re finally ready for your next (and best) chapter in Atlanta—and now you’re staring down one of the biggest decisions of your life: Do you buy an existing home and make it work, or team up with a custom home builder in Atlanta to create the forever home you’ve always dreamed of?
We get it–saying this decision is overwhelming would be an understatement. Atlanta’s real estate market is fierce, and the thought of building a new home might seem out of reach at first thought. But with the right builder and the right plan, building a custom home in Atlanta might actually be more realistic—and more rewarding—than you think.
Let’s break down both options so you can make the decision that’s right for you and your future. Hint: It’s the one that gives you the most options.
Table Of Contents:
- The Pros and Cons of Buying a Home In Atlanta
- Why More Atlanta Homeowners Are Choosing To Build In 2025
- Is It Cheaper To Build Or Buy A Home In Atlanta In 2025?
- How Long Does It Take to Build a Home in Atlanta?
- Design Decisions Don’t Have to Be a Headache
- Why 2025 Is The Best Time To Build A Home In Atlanta
- Why Choose Midtown Builders Group as Your Custom Home Builder In Atlanta
The Pros and Cons of Buying a Home In Atlanta
Pros
Let’s see why buying a home in Atlanta is a good choice for most homeowners.
Buying A Home Is More Affordable
The biggest reason why homeowners choose to buy an existing home is that it’s much cheaper to buy than it is to build because of the lower upfront cost. The average listing price in Atlanta today sits at $402,035, which is about 4 percent lower than 2024. In general, it’s cheaper to purchase a pre-built home than to go through the full home building process — especially in high-demand markets like Atlanta. You’re not paying for architectural design, or all the building costs – just the home itself.
Faster Move-In
The average buyer in Atlanta takes around 4 to 6 months to complete the home-buying process—from initial search to moving in. With proper preparation and market knowledge, it can go faster. Being pre-approved and ready puts you ahead of the competition in a market where listings tend to move in about 50 days. Buying a home in areas like Brookhaven, West Midtown, or East Atlanta can often get you the keys within 30–60 days. Need to move soon? Buying is a better option for you.
Less Decisions, Less Stress
Buying a home is like picking a meal off an Italian restaurant: You get to choose what already looks good, and you don’t have to create your own pasta and sauce from scratch. The seasoning, sides, and presentation are already set. (But if you’re picky or have a specific taste, you might leave wishing you’d just cooked it yourself…) With homes, you don’t have to pick out the colors, finishes, floor plan, or all the other decisions that come with building a home–you just have to pick what’s already out there.
Cons
Before you decide to dial that realtor’s number, make sure you’re aware of the disadvantages of buying a home in Atlanta.
Renovation Nightmares Hiding In Your Home
Although buying a home is cheaper than building, cheaper doesn’t always mean better. That charming bungalow in Sandy Springs might come with a roof that needs replacing or plumbing issues hiding behind the walls–a year after you move in… Atlanta’s older houses can come with costly renovation nightmares that inspectors can’t always predict.
You might also move-in thinking your new home is “good enough” only to realize that you should’ve gone with an open floor plan or hardwood floors instead of carpet. Move-in regret is real for homeowners who had to make compromises on the home they move into. Enter the remodeling phase…
Bidding Wars – What Keeps Families From Moving
For most homeowners, the hardest part isn’t deciding to move to Atlanta–it’s getting the house they actually want. In a competitive city like Atlanta, going mano-a-mano with multiple different bidders is not only inevitable–but extremely exhausting when you lose house after house. It’s the reason why some families end up staying in the same place for another 5 years (or give up moving entirely). If you’re facing off against some stubborn gladiator bidders, don’t fall in love with your Plan A home.
Speaking of Plan A homes…
You Won’t Love Every Home 100%
When you buy a home, it’s rare to fall in love with every square inch. Maybe the paint is a little too dark, the kitchen doesn’t quite have the space you imagined, or the layout feels just slightly off. After all—you’re stepping into someone else’s idea of a dream home, not your own. When you’re house hunting, you probably won’t find a home that checks off every box to the tee, even your top picks.
Why More Atlanta Homeowners Are Choosing To Build In 2025
Now for the big reveal. Here’s why more and more homeowners are taking matters into their own hands (and homes).
Your Dream Home Built Exactly How You Want
The greatest part about building your own home? You’re in the driver’s seat. From the floor plan to the paint swatches, you get to make every decision, big or small. Want an open-concept kitchen with floor-to-ceiling windows? Done. Dreaming of a dramatic staircase or custom mudroom? Say no more.
Every element is chosen with your family’s lifestyle and taste in mind. And since you’re building new, you also get access to today’s latest energy-efficient technology—saving you money on utilities and giving your home a modern edge that older homes just can’t match.
Avoiding Expensive Renovations
Older homes may come with charm—but they’re also waiting to be broken. From aging pipes to hidden water damage, buying existing means you could be signing up for expensive repairs you didn’t see coming.
But with a brand-new build, you skip the surprise renovations and step into a home that will stand the test of time–both in style and durability. Instead of fixing someone else’s problems, you’ll enjoy peace of mind knowing every wall, wire, and fixture is brand new and built to last.
A Legacy You Can Live In
There’s something deeply satisfying about living in a home that was built just for you. Every hallway, window, and detail reflects your vision—not someone else’s. You’re not just moving into a new house, you’re moving into your own art. No settling for a home you pretend to love with your whole heart, just pride in knowing you designed the place where memories will be made for years to come.
Is It Cheaper To Build Or Buy A Home In Atlanta In 2025?
It’s no secret that building a home is much more expensive than buying. You’re building an entire estate from scratch after all. Throw in the contractor, land purchase, insurance, and materials cost, and it definitely adds up before you know it. Costs for building a home in Atlanta can range from $300,000 to $700,000 for construction alone. But of course, building your dream home is naturally a bigger investment. For an exact quote, you’ll have to contact a custom home builder in Atlanta with your home needs.
How Long Does It Take to Build a Home in Atlanta?
How long it takes to build your custom home in Atlanta depends on who your contractors are. Building a home in Atlanta from the initial consultation to passing over the keys can take upwards of 6 months to over a year. To some–especially those who need to move out soon–this is a long time. But if you’re not in a hurry and enjoy witnessing big projects coming to life, this is more a pro for you then a con!
If you’ve been dreaming and planning for this, and aren’t in a rush to move, the construction process often flies by. And let’s be honest, there’s something incredibly exciting about watching your home take shape from the ground up. It’s a once-in-a-lifetime experience that most people never get to witness.
This family loves watching their new home being built more than catching Saturday morning cartoons!
Design Decisions Don’t Have to Be a Headache
Unless you’ve already sketched out your dream home down to the last cabinet pull (and let’s be real—most people haven’t), you’re going to face a lot of decisions. Maybe you’ve binged some HGTV and have a vibe in mind, but figuring out the exact floor plan or finishes? That can feel overwhelming.
But here’s the good news: You don’t need to have it all figured out. A great design-build team will guide you through the process, help you narrow down your style, show you layouts that fit your lifestyle, and make choosing everything from paint colors to countertops surprisingly fun—not stressful.
Why 2025 Is The Best Time To Build A Home In Atlanta
There’s never been a better time to build your new custom home than this year. Here’s why:
You Get What You Want—Not Just What’s Available
Atlanta’s resale market can be competitive and full of compromises. Building a custom home gives you full control over layout, finishes, and features—no settling for that outdated kitchen or awkward layout. Whether you want a mid-century modern look in Buckhead or a farmhouse style in the suburbs, you design it to fit your lifestyle, not someone else’s past preferences.
Today’s Homes Save You Lots Of Money In The Long Run
Building in 2025 means getting today’s latest innovations—energy-efficient HVAC systems, smart home tech, and durable low-maintenance materials. These upgrades save you money long-term and boost your home’s resale value. You’re building a house that’s future-ready, rather than patching up a house from the past.
Atlanta Still Has Room For You (For Now!)
While areas like Midtown and Virginia-Highland are well-established, Atlanta still offers great land opportunities in up-and-coming neighborhoods and surrounding suburbs like Smyrna, Brookhaven, and East Point. Building now means locking in one of the greatest cities in America while inventory is still available—and potentially watching your property value grow with the city.
Why Choose Midtown Builders Group as Your Custom Home Builder In Atlanta
Building the home you’ve always wanted is a major milestone. That’s why our team of experts gives their full attention to every detail of your home. And we’ve spent the last 25 years crafting exceptional spaces, with over 200+ projects completed, and hundreds of satisfied homeowners–making us the best custom home builder Atlanta has to offer. We live and dream by, “If You Dream It, We Can Build It.”
But don’t just take our word for it. See our work for yourself:
Don’t Just Dream About Your Forever Home. Build It With Midtown Builders Group.
So, you’ve just made the biggest and perhaps the best decision in your life. It’s time to build the home you’ve worked so hard for! You deserve to live in a space that you’ve had the pleasure of creating yourself–so why not build it with the team that cares just as much as you do?
Sources:
Read More: